Don’t get stuck in the performance paradox: Just performing well can be a career-limiting move


The article discusses the concept of the “performance paradox” in the workplace, where employees who consistently perform well may not necessarily be the best fit for leadership positions. It emphasizes the importance of considering other factors such as emotional intelligence and interpersonal skills when identifying potential leaders. The key takeaways for HR leaders include:

1. Performance does not always equate to leadership potential: Just because an employee consistently performs well in their current role does not mean they will be successful in a leadership position. HR leaders should look beyond performance metrics and consider other qualities that are important for effective leadership.

2. Emotional intelligence is crucial for leadership success: Emotional intelligence, which involves the ability to understand and manage one’s emotions and the emotions of others, is a key predictor of leadership success. HR leaders should assess candidates for their emotional intelligence skills and provide training and development opportunities to enhance these skills in existing employees.

3. Interpersonal skills are important for building relationships: Building strong relationships with colleagues, clients, and other stakeholders is crucial for effective leadership. HR leaders should assess candidates for their interpersonal skills, such as communication, collaboration, and conflict resolution, and provide training to develop these skills in employees.

4. Look for potential, not just current performance: HR leaders should focus on identifying employees with potential for growth and development, rather than solely relying on current performance. This can be done through talent assessments, performance reviews, and development programs.

5. Provide leadership development opportunities: HR leaders should invest in leadership development programs to groom potential leaders within the organization. These programs can include training, mentoring, and coaching to enhance leadership skills and prepare employees for future leadership roles.

6. Foster a culture of continuous learning: HR leaders should encourage a culture of continuous learning and growth within the organization. This can be done through providing learning and development opportunities, promoting knowledge sharing, and creating a supportive environment for employees to take risks and learn from failures.

In conclusion, HR leaders should not solely rely on performance metrics when identifying potential leaders. Emotional intelligence, interpersonal skills, potential for growth, and a culture of continuous learning are all important factors to consider when grooming future leaders within the organization.